FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS and ERRATA

Table of Contents

Return to Home Page

  1. Who covers 2nd on balls hit to the OF?
  2. Why would I play the infield deep?
  3. What does N.B. in the Play Book mean?
  4. What is the catchers "H" rating for?
  5. What does it mean ... BR speed (as adjusted)?
  6. What is the difference between a Hard One (H) and Smashed (SM)?
  7. Long Single - 1B*
  8. Loss of Effectiveness (LOE) Penalties
  9. 2BE
  10. 1B? and SS?
  11. 1B+1BE and IH+1BE
  12. Controls
  13. Double Plays (DP's and GB's)
  14. Runner Advancement
  15. "Take a Pitch" strategy
  16. "Pick off" or "Pitch out" strategy
  17. Ratings of fielders
  18. Numbers at the top of the Park Chart
  19. Errata

Who covers 2nd on balls hit to the OF?

Answer: On balls hit to right field the shortstop covers second base and the second baseman goes out to be the cutoff man.

On balls hit to left field and center field the second baseman covers second and the shortstop goes out to be the cutoff man.

Back to Top

Why would I play the infield deep?

Answer: By playing a particular group of infielders deep, you are conceding a greater possibility of a runner reaching on a SM, H or T but you are preventing a hit that could result in the runners taking an extra base. For example, a H can result in a 1B, and a SM in a sharp single (SS), both of which would often entail runners advancing farther than they would on an infield hit (IH), especially the 1B. 

Just as importantly, you are also precluding the possibility of costly errors on these types of plays, since the fielder will be in a better position to field a smash or what would be a difficult chance were he playing at normal depth--errors that could result in a one, two or even three base advance! 

Finally, you have the result that certain directional sharp single (SS) results are converted to infield hits (IH), which again could mean the difference between a runner advancing a single base versus two bases.

This strategy might be valuable if there is a runner on second (or first) who represents an important run and you have a good hitter at the plate (and if you have some poor infielders, as it lessens the likelihood of an error). You might be willing to concede a higher chance that the batter reaches first in exchange for ensuring that the runner will not advance more than one base on certain types of hits (there is a chance that a BR 3 on second with two outs could attempt to score).

Back to Top

What does N.B. in the Play Book mean?

Answer: It is an abbreviation for the Latin phrase nota bene, meaning "note well." It is used to emphasize an important point.

Back to Top

What is the catchers "H" rating for?

Answer: The catchers "H" rating is a measure of how he "handles" a pitching staff.  The rating determines how many conferences may be called during a game. Conferences are used to negate Loss of Effectiveness (LOE) penalties incurred by the pitcher. Refer to page 24 of the Play Book on how these systems work.

Back to Top

What does it mean ... BR speed (as adjusted)?

Answer: In certain situations, such as when the two middle infielders are playing "half way" or "all the way" in, or if one of the two middle infielders are "cheating" towards second base, the baser runners speed will be adjusted up or down. Refer to page 10 of the Play Book, under paragraph D of the "Positioning of Fielders" section.

Back to Top

What is the difference between a Hard One (H) and Smashed (SM)?

Answer: "The H is the most difficult chance play to confront an infielder. Its error factor is greater than an SM. Both the H and the SM reach the infielder in the air, but the latter is not hit as hard, with the result that a fielder is more likely to knock the ball down (if not to catch it) and hence make the play. The H, if caught, will more often result in a runner on base being doubled up. You will see on the park charts how a good fielder can make a great play on this ball on occasion. No SS hits result from an H that goes through the infield because it is a ball (unlike the SM) that is hit further to either side of the fielder and also one that does not go directly to the relevant outfielder. To put another way, an H play made is a great defensive play, while an SM play made is a good defensive play made."

Back to Top

Long Single - 1B*

Question #1: The batter hits a long single (1B*) with runners on 1st and 2nd. The runner on 2nd is (automatically) safe at home and the runner on 1st is (automatically) safe at third. Proceeding to the (*) Hit Advance Chart on page 5 of the Play Book, the batter safely advances an extra base, into second. How do you score this type of play? Is it a double for the batter, or do you consider the batter to have taken 2nd on the throw?

Answer #1: In the scenario described it's a double.

In this particular instance it's a double because no play was made on either the runner who scored or the runner who reached 3rd safely. Credit the batter reaching 2nd on his base running instincts and dilatory fielding by the defense. If a play had been made on either of the runners and the batter then advanced to 2nd safely in the process (as directed by the runners advancing chart), it would be a single.

Question #2: The batter has hit a long single (1B*) with a runner at first base. I refer to the "Advancing From First Base" chart to determine where the runner on first base lands, and I get a "Must Advance Chart" reference. In referring to the "Must Advance Chart" it states that the runner at first is safely into third, but no trail runners can advance. Can I still use the * on the 1B* to see if the batter legs out an extra base hit?

Answer #2: No, the batter must hold at first despite the fact the * in the 1B* has not been played out. The instructions for the advancement of trail runners on the "Must Advance Chart take precedence over the *. The * on 1B* and 2B* can only come into play if the runners ahead of the batter automatically reach the their respective bases.

Once the base runners are referenced to the "Must Advance Chart" their advancement is no longer automatic, and all subsequent trail runner advancement is handled by the "Must Advance Chart" or any subsequent chart that it refers you to..

Question #3: The batter has hit a long single (1B*) or a long double (2B*), and there is no base runner in front of them, that would prohibit their further advancement. However, I would prefer that they don't attempt to take the extra base. Can I hold them to a single or double?

Answer #3: In this instance the batter must attempt to take the extra base. The attempt of taking the extra base, when applicable, is not optional unless the batter is in "Wait & See" mode.

The offensive manager has no choice on the advancement of the batter, unless before the batter bats, the offensive manager announces that the batter is in "Wait & See" mode. If the batter is in "Wait & See" mode, the taking of the extra base on a 1B* or 2B* hit is optional. However, when in the "Wait & See" mode the batter loses numbers 31 to 40 on the (*) HIT ADVANCE CHART ... and he can only advance the extra base on a dice roll of 41 to 45.

See page 1 of the Play Book (under section A.2. - "Wait & See) and page 5 ((*) HIT ADVANCE CHART) for further clarification.

Question #4: If a pitcher has a control for singles (1B), does this also apply to a long single (1B*) result on the batter's card?

Answer #4: Yes, it does.

Check out the Runner Advancement topic for further discussion on Long Singles (1B*).

Back to Top

Loss of Effectiveness (LOE) Penalties

Question: Here is how the inning unfolded ... the first batter singled, the second batter reached on an error and the third batter singled. The bases are now loaded with no one out. Does this mean that the second penalty comes into play i.e., #50 becomes a 2B8 and #49 becomes a 1B7? I do not believe it does, because I have not had two hits followed by another batter reaching first (whether on a hit or not), in which no one was retired? Am I correct?

Answer: No, that is not correct. However, I can see your confusion. The rule states; "After two hits plus one other batter reaching base safely (whether on a hit or not) ... " Depending on how you read this rule it can be a bit misleading. It would be better if it read, "Once two hits and one other batter reaching base safely (whether on a hit or not) ... " In the scenario you describe, the second penalty does come into play. It comes into play because two hits were made and another batter reached safely, and no base runners were put out on any of those plays. It does not matter if the batter that reaches safely (whether on a hit or not) does so, before the two hits, or after the two hits.

There are three LOE penalties that can take place in Ball Park Baseball.

1) the first penalty is when #50 becomes a 2B8

2) the second penalty is when #50 becomes a 2B8 and #49 becomes a 1B7

3) the third penalty is when #50 becomes a 2B8, #49 becomes a 1B7, #48 becomes a 1B9, #47 becomes a WP, and #46 becomes a PB

Note that these penalties do not necessarily come into play in the order specified. The first two penalties require hits before either of those penalties can come into play. The third penalty can come into play, without any hits whatsoever. The third penalty can in fact be invoked without the first two ever coming into play.

Understanding the term "on which no one was retired" is the key to comprehending the LOE penalties.

A hit in which no one is retired occurs if the batter records a base hit and none of the runners on base, *or the batter*, are retired on *that play*. The same holds true if a batter walks, or a batter reaches base as a result of an error and neither the batter nor any of the base runners are retired on that play.  These events satisfy the requirement stated in the LOE rules of a "play in which no one is retired."

If the batter is struck out by the pitcher, or flies out, or simply makes an out on his own, that does not comply with the term "on which no one was retired."

Here are some scenarios:

A) The first batter of the inning doubles. The second batter pops out to third. The third batter strikes out. The fourth batter singles and the runner on second scores. The second hit of the inning means the pitcher invokes the 1st penalty (#50 becomes a 2B8). The penalty is invoked even though the second and third batters of the inning were retired. The two hits in the inning do not have to be consecutive.

B) The first two batters in the inning reach safely on hits. There are now runners on 1st and 2nd. The pitcher has now invoked the first penalty (#50 becomes a 2B8) immediately after giving up the two base hits. The third batter strikes out. The fourth batter hits a grounder to the pitcher and the pitcher throws the ball away for an error and everyone is safe. The bases are now loaded. Note that on the two hits and the error there was no incident "on which a player was retired." In this scenario the pitcher would now invoke the second penalty after the error (#49 becomes a 1B7) even though the previous batter struck out.

C) Same scenario as above for the first three batters. The first two batters reached safely on hits and the third batter struck out. There are now runners at 1st and 2nd and one out. The pitcher has now invoked the first penalty (#50 becomes a 2B8) because of the two hits. The fourth batter then hits a grounder to the pitcher and the pitcher throws to second and the ball skips into center field for an error. The runner on second comes all the way around to score and the center fielder then throws out the runner from first, at third. The batter in this instance reached 1st on the throwing error by the pitcher and then took second on the throw to third. If the pitchers throw to second had not skipped into center field, the batter would have hit into a 1-4 force out. As it is, the batter reached safely because of an error. The difference between this scenario and that described in scenario B, is that there was an out on the play. The runner from first was thrown out at third, therefore the second LOE penalty does not come into play.

D) The first batter of the inning walks. The second batter grounds out to third, 5-3, with the runner on 1st reaching second. The third batter walks. The fourth batter singles and the bases are now loaded with one out. The fifth batter reaches on an error by the second baseman, everyone is safe, the bases are still loaded with the runner on third scoring. We have now had four batters successfully reach base, where no outs occurred on any of those plays that they reached base on. Even though the second batter made out, the pitcher has now invoked the third LOE penalty. The pitcher has by-passed the first two penalties and jumped directly to the third.

E) The first batter of the inning singles. The second batter pops out to third. With the third batter at the plate, the runner on first is caught stealing second. The fourth batter then doubles. The pitcher has now invoked the first penalty (#50 becomes a 2B8), because he has given up two hits, on which no one was retired. It does not matter that the first batter (who singled) was subsequently thrown out stealing. His out did not occur on a hit, or when another batter reached first. The fifth batter then singles, scoring the runner from second. The pitcher has now invoked the second penalty (#49 becomes a 1B7) because after the two hits, a third batter reached safely, with no other runners being retired, on the same play that he reached safely.

Back to Top

2BE

Question: I had the following result  occur directly on the pitchers card ... 2BE6. Is this a double with an error also being charged to the shortstop, or is it a two base error by the shortstop? If this is a two base error, why doesn't the shortstop have any input on this play?

Answer: It is a 2 base error by the shortstop (not a double + an error).  Be sure to consult the instruction for advancement for a 2BE on the top of page 3 in the Play Book.

These errors are built into the game, based in part on the proportion of unearned runs yielded by the pitcher and, it's assumed, on the number of errors committed by position on that team.  This may be a way to refine error tendencies, provided that players are used as they were in real-life (i.e., playing behind the same pitching staff).

Back to Top

1B? and SS?

Question #1: Am I correct in reading the control on the pitchers card that states, "P card 1B? SS? with none out from 2nd inning of game on becomes PO5" I'm interpreting that this control does not apply in the first inning, or in any subsequent inning if someone was retired. Am I correct?

Answer #1: Yes, you are reading the 1B? hits and SS? hits correctly.  The question mark is a prompt to check from the second inning on with no one out.  It is to be disregarded in the 1st inning and when there are one or two outs from the second inning on, thus, in those cases, they would be scored either as a hit or sharp single.

Question #2: The result on the pitcher's card is 1B?7 (there are outs in the inning). The batter has a control rating that states all 1B and SS become PO6. Does the batters control apply to the 1B? reading or only to 1B and SS on the pitcher card? Is the play a single or PO?

Answer #2: The batters 1B and SS controls also apply to the 1B, 1B?, 1B* or  SS?, outcomes on the pitchers card. So the outcome should be a PO.

Note: With regard to the controls for 1B, SS (including 1B? or SS?), or TL, these apply only to these symbols literally on the opposing players card. If a batter has controls that negate a 1B or SS off the pitchers card ... and the result is either a 1B or SS (including 1B? or SS?) on the pitcher's card, then the batter will not get the hit. But if the pitchers card refers to a park chart reference (e.g., a SM, H, L, etc.) and this leads to a 1B or SS ... then the batter will get the hit.

Further Note: However, if you see a control for "singles" or "hits" (the words are written out), these controls apply to the opposing players card and any subsequent park chart reference. This effectively means, that a player with these controls cannot get "singles" or "hits" from any source.

Back to Top

1B+1BE and IH+1BE

Question: I just had a 1B+1BE occur off a reference on the park chart, not directly from the pitchers card. On page 1 of the play book in paragraph H it states, "On all pitchers cards that read 1B+1BE or IH+1BE, batter then trapped off 2nd base."

My question is ... if I get a result of 1B+1BE or IH+1BE on a park chart reference is it handled the same way as noted above.

Answer: A 1B+1BE or IH+1BE from a park chart reference is treated differently than one coming directly off a pitchers card. If they come off a park chart reference every runner advances two bases and the batter winds up at 2nd base.

The batter is only trapped off 2nd base if the 1B+1BE or IH+1BE comes off the pitchers card, literally.

Back to Top

Controls

Question #1: The result on the pitchers card is L8. After referring to the park chart the result is a home run. However, the batter has a control rating that states all HR on the pitchers card become 1B8. I am assuming it was a HR since the reading came off the Park chart and not the Pitchers card. Is that correct?

Answer #1: No, that is not correct. It is not a HR. The HR control applies to symbols literally on the opposing players card as well as to park chart references that arise from the opposing players card.

Note: With regard to the controls for 1B, SS, or TL, these apply only to these symbols literally on the opposing players card. If a batter has controls that negate a 1B or SS off the pitchers card ... and the result is either a 1B or SS on the pitcher's card, then the batter will not get the hit. But if the pitchers card refers to a park chart reference (e.g., a SM, H, L, etc.) and this leads to a 1B or SS ... then the batter will get the hit.

Further Note: However, if you see a control for "singles" or "hits" (the words are written out), these controls apply to the opposing players card and any subsequent park chart reference. This effectively means, that a player with these controls cannot get "singles" or "hits" from any source.

Question #2: My batter has a control that states all DP's become PO4.  I obtained a GB4 result on the pitchers card that took me to the Pivot Man chart. The Pivot Man chart result indicated a double play. I am assuming that the batter hit into a double play, because the result did not come directly off a DPx result on the pitchers card?  Is that correct?

Answer #2: No, that is not correct. The batters DP control also applies to GB results that lead to a Pivot Man chart reference.

Back to Top

Double Plays (DP's and GB's)

Question: Does a DP control number on a batter card apply only to strict DP results from the pitcher card, or does it also apply to DPs which arise from (for example) pivot man plays on GB results?

Answer: It applies to both (a straight DP result and double play arising from a GB result).

Note: See the CONTROLS topic for more discussion on Double Plays.

Back to Top

Runner Advancement

Question #1: I have a runner on first with no one out. The batter singles to center (1B8). The runner on 1st has a 4 run rating and the hit value adds ten. The total is 14 (no outs) ... so it reads use column "B" for advance to 3rd. Do I have to try to advance even if I am in "Normal" mode with my first base runner, or can I stay at second, so I don't run myself out of an inning?

Answer #1: If the runner is in "Normal" mode, you must roll on column B of the Must Advance Chart and incur the risks involved. Had the runner been in "Wait and See" mode, you would have had the option of not advancing (as all "must advances" are converted to "may advance"). 

However, the flexibility afforded by the "Wait & See" mode comes at a price; namely, if you do decide to advance, an A column advance now becomes a B column advance, and a B column advance becomes "no advance possible." Note, however, that an automatic safe or hold outcome (e.g., 9-12: safe at third base) is not affected by this. Of course, if the runner was in the "Hold (station)" mode, the runner would only have advanced one base, and that would be all.

Note: On a SS (Sharp Single), the offensive manager always has the option to hold the runner to a 1 base advance and not risk the extra base advance.

Question #2: I'm confused on some aspects regarding trail runner advancement. I'm uncertain where the trail runners land, prior to carrying out the instructions for trail runners advancing in the "Must Advance Chart." How do I determine where the runners land, before implementing their further advancement?

Answer #2: There is a basic assumption that is not noted in older versions of the play book and perhaps this will clarify things. The basic assumption is ... On plays on the lead runner, other runners and the batter advance one base on all singles (also1B*) and two bases on 2B or 2B*; then follow "Result of the Play" instructions for further outcomes.

In the case of  runners on first and second and the batter hits a single, or long single (1B*) that results in a play on the runner from second, at home plate, this means that the runner on first takes second, and the batter takes first ... and from that point, you then determine the outcome of the play on the runner at the plate, and then you follow the subsequent trail runner instructions in the "Must Advance Chart."

In the case of a runner at second and the batter hits a double, or long double (2B*) that results in a play on the runner from second, at home plate, this means that the batter takes second ... and from that point, you determine the outcome of the play on the runner at the plate, and then you follow the subsequent trail runner instructions in the "Must Advance Chart."

Question #3: On the "Must Advanced Chart" under Column A - results 2-13, or Column B - results 2-3, if no other base runners are present, is the batter considered as the "next farthest base runner," or is he considered "others?"

Answer #3: He is considered as the "next farthest base runner." By being the only base runner, he is actually the "next farthest" and the "least advanced." At any rate, if the batters speed is 3-4 his advancement is uncontested. If the batters speed is 5-6 he may chance an advance. If the batters speed is 7 or greater he cannot advance.

Check out the Long Single - 1B* topic for further discussion on Runner Advancement.

Back to Top

"Take a Pitch" strategy

Question: After "Take a Pitch" is chosen and the penalty (W or K) is noted, does the offensive manager then get to select another strategy (or "No Strategy") before the at bat is resolved?

Answer: Yes, the offensive manager may elect another strategy, but the penalty remains in effect for that at-bat.

Back to Top

"Pick off" or "Pitch out" strategy

Question: When using "No Strategy" against pickoff or pitchout, and the chart says no additional strategy for that batter, does that apply to both the offense and defense or just the defense? It seems to apply only to the defense and allow the offense the reward of then being able to choose steal or hit and run without fear of another pickoff or pitchout.

Answer: No, all strategy is off for both the offense and the defense for the remainder of that at-bat.

Back to Top

Ratings of fielders

Question: When reading the park chart under "L" are those the fielders ratings along the left side and if they are, why are they grouped like (1,2,4)  (3,5,6) (7,8,9)?  I can see 7-8-9, but why 1-2-4? or 3-5-6?

Answer: Yes, those are the fielding ratings along the left side. The reason they are grouped the way they are is because the hierarchy of fielding ratings is not linear.

Back to Top

Numbers at the top of the Park Chart

Question: The numbers at the top of the park chart, are those the positions of the fielders (i.e. P = 1, C = 2, 1B = 3, etc.), or are they the defensive ratings of the fielder who fielded the ball?

Answer: They're the defensive ratings of the fielder who fielded the ball.

Note: On the "L" section of the park chart the ratings of the fielder who fielded the ball are posted in the left hand column.

Back to Top

Errata

 

PLAYER CARDS

 

1899 SEASON

TOMMY DOWD

Tommy Dowd (Cleveland Spiders -1899) - Dowd should be CF  1.
Dowd is rated to play L-R, but did not play there.

SPORT McALLISTER

Sport McAllister (Cleveland Spiders -1899) - McAllister should be C 4-4-2-6.

CHIEF ZIMMER

Chief Zimmer (Louisville Colonels -1899) - Zimmer should be 1B  9.

CLAUDE RITCHEY

Claude Ritchey (Louisville Colonels -1899) - Ritchey should be SS  7.

 

1901 SEASON

JOE DOLAN

Joe Dolan (Philadelphia Phillies -1901) - Dolan should be 2B  7. Dolan is rated at SS for the Phillies, but did not play there.

 

1903 SEASON

HONUS WAGNER

Honus Wagner (Pittsburgh Pirates -1903) - Wagner should be L-R   3, Arm = 2.

 

1906 SEASON

DOC GESSLER

Doc Gessler (Chicago Cubs -1906) - Gessler should be CF  7.

 

1907 SEASON

FRANK LaPORTE

Frank LaPorte (New York Yankees -1907) - LaPorte should be CF  9.

 

1909 SEASON

DAVY JONES

Davy Jones (Detroit Tigers -1909) - Jones should be CF  3.

 

1914 SEASON

JOSE DeVORE

Josh DeVore (Boston Braves - 1914) - DeVore should be CF  9.

LES MANN

Les Mann (Boston Braves -1914) - Mann should be L-R   4.

 

1915 SEASON

BUD WEISER

Bud Weiser (Philadelphia Phillies - 1915) - Weiser should be CF  9.

DODE PASKERT

Dode Paskert (Philadelphia Phillies - 1915) - Paskert should be L-R   3.

 

1918 SEASON

TURNER BARBER

Turner Barber (Chicago Cubs - 1918) - Barber should be CF  9.

 

1921 SEASON

CHICK FEWSTER

Chick Fewster (New York Yankees - 1921) - Fewster should be CF  7.

BRAGGO ROTH

Braggo Roth (New York Yankees - 1921) - Roth should be CF  9.

 

1924 SEASON

JIMMY O'CONNELL

Jimmy O'Connell (New York Giants - 1924) - O'Connell should be CF  9.

HACK WILSON

Hack Wilson (New York Giants - 1924) - Wilson should be L-R   2.

SAM RICE

Sam Rice (Washington Senators -1924) - Rice should be CF  9 and L-R   5.

 

1927 SEASON

KIKI CUYLER

Kiki Cuyler (Pittsburgh Pirates -1927) - Cuyler should be CF  5.

 

1930 SEASON

EARL CLARK

Earl Clark (Boston Braves -1930) - Clark should be CF  5.

BUSTER CHATHAM

Buster Chatham (Boston Braves -1930) - Chatham should be SS  7.

RANDY MOORE

Randy Moore (Boston Braves -1930) - Moore should be CF  8.

WALLY BERGER

Wally Berger (Boston Braves -1930) - Berger should be L-R  5, CF  0.
Berger is shown as playing CF, but did not play there.

 

1932 SEASON

SAMMY BYRD

Sammy Byrd (New York Yankees -1932) - Byrd should be CF  9.

EARLE COMBS

Earle Combs (New York Yankees -1932) - Combs should be L-R   2.

 

1935 SEASON

GEE WALKER

Gee Walker (Detroit Tigers -1935) - Walker should be CF  6.

 

1938 SEASON

CARL REYNOLDS

Carl Reynolds (Chicago Cubs -1938) - Reynolds should be L-R   2.

WOODY JENSEN

Woody Jensen (Pittsburgh Pirates -1938) - Jensen should be CF   9.

 

1941 SEASON

STAN SPENCE

Stan Spence (Boston Red Sox -1941) - Spence should be L-R   7, Arm = 2.

TOMMY HENRICH

Tommy Henrich (New York Yankees -1941) - Henrich should be CF  8.

FRENCHY BORDAGARAY

Frenchy Bordagaray (New York Yankees -1941) - Bordagaray should be L-R   9, Arm = 4. Bordagaray is rated for CF, but did not play there.

 

1946 SEASON

BUSTER ADAMS

Buster Adams (St. Louis Cardinals -1946) - Adams' card incorrectly reads "Babe" Adams. He shoud be CF  7.

HARRY WALKER

Harry Walker (St. Louis Cardinals -1946) - Walker should be L-R   4.

 

1947 SEASON

CARL FURILLO

Carl Furillo (Brooklyn Dodgers -1947) - Furillo should be L-R   2.

DUKE SNIDER

Duke Snider (Brooklyn Dodgers -1947) - Snider should be L-R   5.

 

1948 SEASON

CLINT CONASTER

Clint Conaster (Boston Braves -1948) - Conaster should be CF  9.

MIKE McCORMICK

Mike McCormick (Boston Braves -1948) - McCormick should be CF  6, and L-R  5.

LARRY DOBY

Larry Doby (Cleveland Indians -1948) - Doby should be L-R  4.

WALLY JUDNICH

Wally Judnich (Cleveland Indians -1948) - Judnich should be CF  8, and 1B  5.

 

1950 SEASON

DICK WHITMAN

Dick Whitman (Philadelphia Phillies -1950) - Whitman should be CF  8.

 

1955 SEASON

BARNEY SCHULTZ

Barney Schultz (St. Louis Cardinals -1955) - Schultz should be designated as a Knuckler.

 

1959 SEASON

BUBBA PHILLIPS

Bubba Phillips (Chicago White Sox -1959) - Phillips should be CF  7.

 

1961 SEASON

JACK REED

Jack Reed (New York Yankees -1961) - Reed should be L-R   9.

 

1962 SEASON

BARNEY SCHULTZ

Barney Schultz (Chicago Cubs -1962) - Schultz should be designated as a Knuckler.

RICHIE ASHBURN

Richie Ashburn (New York Mets -1962) - Ashburn should be CF  8.

JIM HICKMAN

Jim Hickman (New York Mets -1962) - Hickman should be L-R  5.

TOMMY DAVIS

Tommy Davis (Los Angeles Dodgers -1962) - Davis should be CF  9.

DUKE SNIDER

Duke Snider (Los Angeles Dodgers -1962) - Snider should be L-R  9.

 

1963 SEASON

BARNEY SCHULTZ

Barney Schultz (St. Louis Cardinals -1963) - Schultz should be designated as a Knuckler.

 

1964 SEASON

BARNEY SCHULTZ

Barney Schultz (St. Louis Cardinals -1964) - Schultz should be designated as a Knuckler.

COOKIE ROJAS

Cookie Rojas (Philadelphia Phillies -1964) - Rojas should be CF  9.

BOB MEYER

Bob Meyer (Kansas City Athletics -1964) - Meyer's 1B?, SS? control rating outcome is cut off at the bottom of the card. It should be "P02."

DICK  RADATZ 

Dick Radatz (Boston Red Sox - 1964) - Radatz' 1B?, SS? control rating outcome is cut off at the bottom of the card. It should be "P04."

 

1965 SEASON

BARNEY SCHULTZ

Barney Schultz (St. Louis Cardinals -1965) - Schultz should be designated as a Knuckler.

 

1967 SEASON

JOSE TARTABULL 

Jose Tartabull (Boston Red Sox -1967) - Tartabull should be CF  7.

 

1968 SEASON

JIM NORTHRUP

Jim Northrup (Detroit Tigers -1968) - Northrup should be CF  6.

 

1969 SEASON

ROD GASPAR

Rod Gaspar (New York Mets -1969) - Gaspar should be CF  7.

AMOS OTIS

Amos Otis (New York Mets -1969) - Otis should be L-R  7.

HANK ALLEN

Hank Allen (Washington Senators -1969) - Allen should be CF  9.

CESAR TOVER

Cesar Tover (Minnesota Twins -1969) - Tovar should be L-R  2.

 

1971 SEASON

MERV RETTENMUND

Merv Rettenmund (Baltimore Orioles -1971) - Rettenmund should be CF  6.

 

1973 SEASON

ALLAN LEWIS

Allan Lewis (Oakland Athlietics - 1973) - Lewis does not have a card and he should be carded.

 

1976 SEASON

ROY WHITE

Roy White (New York Yankees -1976) - White should be CF  7.

 

1977 SEASON

MATT ALEXANDER

Matt Alexander (Oakland Athletics - 1977) - Alexander has no CF rating on his card. He should have a CF rating and it should be CF: 7 with Arm: 6.

Matt Alexander also has no SS rating on his card despite the fact he made 12 appearance as a Shortstop. This is because in those 12 appearance he had no chances.  

LARRY LINTZ

Larry Lintz (Oakland Athletics - 1977) - Lintz has no 2B rating on his card. He should have a 2B rating and it should be 2B: 7.

SHELDON MALLORY

Sheldon Mallory (Oakland Athletics - 1977) - Mallory has no CF rating on his card. He should have a CF rating and it should be CF: 8 with Arm: 3.

MARTY PEREZ

Marty Perez (Oakland Athletics - 1977) - Perez has no 3B rating on his card. He should have a 3B rating and it should be 3B: 4.

TONY ARMAS

Tony Armas (Oakland Athletics -1977) - Armas should be CL-R  2.

LARRY MURRAY

Larry Murray (Oakland Athletics -1977) - Murray should be CF  7.

JOHN HALE

John Hale (Los Angeles Dodgers -1977) - Hale should be CF  8.

 

1978 SEASON

PAUL BLAIR

Paul Blair (New York Yankees -1978) - Blair should be L-R  7.

 

1979 SEASON

LARRY HARLOW

Larry Harlow (California Angels -1979) - Harlow should be CF  9.

MARK COREY

Mark Corey (Baltimore Orioles - 1979) - Corey does not have a card and he should be carded.

 

1980 SEASON

GARY WOODS

Gary Woods (Houston Astros -1980) - Woods should be L-R  7.
Woods is rated at CF despite never playing there.

GREG GROSS

Greg Gross (Philadelphia Phillies -1980) - Gross should be CF  9.

DEL UNSER

Del Unser (Philadelphia Phillies -1980) - Unser should be CF  3.

 

1981 SEASON

DAVE WINFIELD

Dave Winfield (New York Yankees -1981) - Winfield should be CF  5.

 

1982 SEASON

BOBBY BROWN

Bobby Brown (Seattle Mariners -1982) - Brown should be CF  6.

JOE SIMPSON

Joe Simpson (Seattle Mariners -1982) - Simpson should be L-R  5.

STEVE STROUGHTER

Steve Stroughter (Seattle Mariners - 1982) - Stroughter does not have a card and he should be carded.

MARSHALL EDWARDS

Marshall Edwards (Milwaukee Brewers -1982) - Edwards should be CF  5.

 

1984 SEASON

RUSTY KUNTZ

Rusty Kuntz (Detroit Tigers -1984) - Kuntz should be CF  8.

 

1985 SEASON

LYNN JONES

Lynn Jones (Kansas City Royals -1985) - Jones should be CF  8.

 

1987 SEASON

MARK DAVIDSON

Mark Davidson (Minnesota Twins -1987) - Davidson should be CF  7.

 

1988 SEASON

MIKE DAVIS

Mike Davis (Los Angeles Dodgers -1988) - Davis should be CF  9.

JOSE GONZALEZ

Jose Gonzalez (Los Angeles Dodgers - 1988) - Gonzalez does not have a card and he should be carded.

 

1989 SEASON

MITCH WEBSTER

Mitch Webster (Chicago Cubs -1989) - Webster should be CF  6.

1990 SEASON

ROBERTO KELLY

Roberto Kelly (New York Yankees - 1990) - Kelly should be CF 2 and L-R 1.

DEION SANDERS

Deion Sanders (New York Yankees - 1990) - Sanders should be CF 9 and L-R 9.

 

1991 SEASON

JARVIS BROWN

Jarvis Brown (Minnesota Twins - 1991) - Brown should be CF 9.

KIRBY PUCKETT

Kirby Puckett (Minnesota Twins - 1991) - Puckett should be L-R  2.

CECIL ESPY

Cecil Espy (Pittsburgh Pirates - 1991) - Espy should not have a L-R  Rating. He did not play there.

GARY REDUS

Gary Redus (Pittsburgh Pirates - 1991) - Redus should be L-R  9.

 

1992 SEASON

TOM QUINLAN

Tom Quinlan (Toronto Blue Jays - 1992) - Quinlan does not have a card and he should be carded.

 

1995 SEASON

RUBEN AMARO

Ruben Amaro (Cleveland Indians - 1995) - Amaro should be L-R  4.

JERALD CLARK

Jerald Clark (Minnesota Twins - 1995) - Clark should be CF  1.

 

2006 SEASON

ESTEBAN GERMAN

Esteban German (Kansas City Royals - 2006) - German has no L-R rating on his card. He should have a L-R rating and it should be L-R: 4.

Back to Top


STADIUMS

GREAT AMERICAN BALLPARK - CINCINNATI (2003-)

Great American Ballpark - There is an error on the SF-D Chart under results 46-50 for the 6, 7, 8 and 9 outfielders. The correct result should read as follows:

If ball hit to LF or RF, combine fielding of LF-CF or RF-CF;  if hit to CF add 4 to fielding;  2-12= OUT; 13-15= Z;
16+= 1B

GRIFFITH STADIUM (Park Chart) - WASHINGTON AL (1911-1955)

Griffith Stadium - There is an error on the T-SM Chart under results 46-50. The correct results should read as follows:

Same as above, except if ball hit to third baseman (3B), shortstop (SS), second baseman (2B), or first baseman (1B): then, combine fielding of 3B with SS or 2B with 1B for result; 2-13=same as above; 14-15=X; 16+=IH

NEW BUSCH STADIUM (Park Chart) - ST. LOUIS NL (2006-)

Busch Stadium - There is an error on the Park's "Pop Up Factor." It currently reads:
 1-20= consult Play Book
21-35= foul, not caught
29-50= foul, caught

I
t should read:
 1-20= consult Play Book
21-35= foul, not caught
36-50= foul, caught

RFK STADIUM (Park Chart) - WASHINGTON NL (2005-)

RFK Stadium - There is an error on the SF-D Chart for a 2 rated outfielder as there is no #4 dice roll result. The correct result for #4 is "Y."

RFK STADIUM (Park Chart) - WASHINGTON AL (1962-1971)

RFK Stadium - There is an error on the SF-D Chart for a 2 rated outfielder as there is no #4 dice roll result. The correct result for #4 is "Y."

SHIBE PARK (Park Chart) - PHILADELPHIA NL (1938-1970)

Shibe Park - There is an error on the H Chart for a 6 rated infielder. The 1BE should read "33-35, not "34-35."

WRIGLEY FIELD (Park Chart) - CHICAGO NL (1916-)

Wrigley Field - There is an error on the left field results of the "L" chart for the 7, 8 and 9 rated fielders. The correct results should read as follows:

1B     27-33
2B*    34-40
OUT    41-50

Back to Top


PLAY BOOK

Page 8 - There is appears to be an error on the 3rd play result (3rd down from the top of the page) it reads: Force at second; batter safe. If catcher (2nd baseman if play is at home) is 4-10 fielder, then all runners advance one more base on pivot man's error. 

It is not an error. Mr. Sidman describes the play as follows: The intent here is to allow the catcher, who is presumed to be backing up the play at first, save the wild throw to first.  For a DP that goes home to first, the second baseman would be in a position to retrieve the errant throw and prevent the error.

Page 33 - Infield Fly Rule under section D has an error. It should read as follows:

"on fair infield fly rule PU which is dropped for error on TL, batter is out but one 3-6 BR may try to advance on play. Draw another number: 3-4 BR runner safe on 1-5, otherwise out; 5-6 BR runner safe on 1-3, otherwise out."

There is a second error that appears on page 33. The error appears in the first line of the pop up chart. The incorrect version reads, "TL (if hit to catcher, 1BE in foul territory)." 

It should be corrected to read: "TL (if hit to catcher foul ball dropped for an error, no advance of runners)."

Back to Top

Return to Home Page


Ball Park Baseball FAQ and Errata.
Revised: February 25, 2008 .